| Year |
Recipient |
| 1990 |
William "Pinky" Newell, Purdue University |
| 1991 |
Mel Bickenstaff, Indiana State University
Robert Kerns, Portage High School
Jim Morris, Butler University |
| 1992 |
Robert Behnke Indiana State University
Harold Cordell, Lafayette Jeff High School
Dwayne "Spike" Dixon, Indiana University |
| 1993 |
Jim Dickerson, Ball Sate University
Sayers "Bud" Miller, Ball State University
Marjorie Albohm, Orthopedic Medicine of Indiana |
| 1994 |
Gene Paszkiet, University of Notre Dame
Rod Moore, Valparaiso University |
| 1995 |
Howard Catt, Arsenal Technological High School
David Craig, Indiana Pacers
Glen Snow, Active Ankle Systems |
| 1996 |
Steve Risinger, Anderson University
John Schrader, Indiana University |
| 1997 |
Dennis Miller, Purdue University |
| 1998 |
Sherman Izsak, Merrillville High School
Jack Mansfield, Wabash College
Jim Routhier, Concord High School |
| 1999 |
Ralph Reiff, Butler University
Robert J. Shriner, Jr., Mishawaka High School |
| 2000 |
Kip Smith, Indiana University
Marion Vruggink,West Lafayette High School
Jay Bradley, IUPUI |
| 2001 |
John Coddington, Quest Therapy Services
John Whitmer, University Of Notre Dame |
| 2002 |
Rick Shaw, Women's Hospital of Indianapolis |
| 2003 |
Catherine Grove, Indiana University |
| 2004 |
Joe Harvey , Brebeuf Jesuit Preparatory School |
| 2005 |
Kathy Taylor Remsburg, Franklin College |
| 2006 |
No Inductees |
| 2007 |
Edward "Hunter" Smith, Indianapolis Colts
Larry Leverenz, Purdue University |
| 2008 |
Angie Miller, Avon High School |
|
2009
|
Thomas Weidner, Ball State University
Mark Lahr, Ben Davis High School
|
| 2010 |
Barbara Hallett Caton, Evansville North High School
Bernie Stento, Chesterton High School
|
|
2011
|
Linda Kaminskis, Goshen College
Ned Shannon, University of Indianapolis
|
